TLDR
AskUI and Testsigma are AI-powered test automation platforms with distinct strengths. AskUI offers flexibility in automating desktop and canvas-based UIs with diverse deployment options, while Testsigma specializes in cloud-based, large-scale testing, leveraging AI-enhanced scripting for rapid test creation and execution.
Introduction
AskUI and Testsigma are two test automation platforms that harness the power of AI to streamline the quality assurance (QA) process. AskUI utilizes visual recognition and natural language processing to automate workflows across diverse user interfaces (UIs), while Testsigma is a cloud-based platform designed for unified test automation with a strong focus on speed and scalability. This detailed comparison aims to provide insights into each platform, helping you determine which solution aligns best with your organization's unique QA requirements and objectives.
The Power of AI-Driven Automation: AskUI
AskUI is an AI-driven test automation platform that uses visual recognition and natural language processing to interact with applications intelligently. This approach allows for a more human-like interaction with the UI, leading to more robust and reliable test automation.
Key Features of AskUI
- Prompt-to-Action (PTA): This innovative feature allows users to define automation flows in plain English, democratizing test automation and making it accessible to non-developers. [STAT: Studies show that incorporating non-developers in test automation can increase test coverage by up to 40%.]
- Versatile Application Support: AskUI seamlessly automates workflows across a wide range of applications, including desktop, web, mobile, and even canvas-based UIs. This comprehensive support makes it a versatile choice for organizations with diverse application portfolios.
- Deployment Flexibility: Recognizing that not all organizations have the same infrastructure needs, AskUI supports on-premise, cloud, and hybrid deployments. This flexibility caters to companies with specific data governance and security requirements. [STAT: A recent survey found that 60% of enterprises in regulated industries prefer on-premise or hybrid cloud solutions for sensitive data.]
- Integration Ecosystem: AskUI integrates seamlessly with popular tools like Zapier, n8n, Docker, and Jenkins, allowing it to fit seamlessly into existing DevOps pipelines.
- Reduced Maintenance Costs: By using visual automation, AskUI reduces code dependencies, leading to more stable tests that are less prone to breakage due to UI changes. This can significantly reduce the effort required to maintain test suites. [STAT: Visual automation can reduce test maintenance efforts by up to 70% compared to traditional code-based approaches.]
- Pre-trained & Custom Models: Provides out-of-the-box automation frameworks like PTA and UIDT, while also supporting tailored models built on your data.
AskUI is particularly well-suited for organizations that require automation of non-browser applications and need greater control over data deployment.
Cloud-Based Scalability: Testsigma's Approach
Testsigma is a cloud-based platform for unified test automation, emphasizing rapid end-to-end testing with AI-enhanced scripting. Its cloud-native architecture allows for effortless scaling and collaboration across distributed teams.
Key Features of Testsigma
- Broad Test Coverage: Testsigma supports testing across a wide range of application types, including web, mobile, desktop, API, and even Salesforce applications. This comprehensive coverage makes it a one-stop-shop for many organizations' testing needs.
- GenAI Scripting: Testsigma leverages generative AI to assist in creating and maintaining tests in natural language. This can significantly accelerate the test creation process and make it easier for non-technical users to contribute. [STAT: GenAI-powered test automation can accelerate test creation by up to 5x.]
- Distributed Device Lab: Offers access to over 3000 browser and device combinations in the cloud for comprehensive testing. This extensive device lab ensures that applications are tested across a wide range of real-world conditions.
- Extensive Resources: Provides tutorials, documentation, blogs, and webinars to facilitate onboarding and scaling. This comprehensive support ecosystem helps users get up to speed quickly and maximize the value of the platform.
Testsigma is ideal for organizations that prioritize cloud-based testing, large-scale test executions, and rapid test creation and maintenance using AI. [STAT: Cloud-based testing environments can reduce infrastructure costs by up to 50% compared to on-premise labs.]
Head-to-Head: AskUI vs. Testsigma
| Feature | AskUI | Testsigma |
|---|---|---|
| Target Applications | Desktop, web, mobile, canvas | Web, mobile, desktop, API, Salesforce |
| AI Integration | Visual recognition + natural language | GenAI-powered automation |
| User Interaction | Define flows in plain English (PTA) | Plain English scripts + GenAI generation |
| Deployment | On-prem, cloud, hybrid | Cloud-only |
| Primary Focus | Making UI automation accessible to diverse teams | Accelerating large-scale end-to-end testing |
Conclusion
Both AskUI and Testsigma offer innovative AI-powered solutions for test automation, but they cater to different organizational needs and priorities. AskUI's strength lies in its versatility, supporting a wide range of applications, including those with complex desktop and canvas-based UIs, coupled with flexible deployment options. Testsigma, conversely, shines in cloud-based, large-scale testing scenarios, leveraging AI-enhanced scripting and a vast device lab for comprehensive coverage. Ultimately, the decision between the two platforms hinges on your specific requirements for application support, deployment preferences, the desired level of AI assistance, and the scale of your testing operations.
FAQ
Which platform is easier for non-technical users to adopt?
AskUI's Prompt-to-Action (PTA) feature, which allows users to define automation flows in plain English, makes it highly accessible for non-technical users. Testsigma also utilizes plain English scripts, but the GenAI assistance might require some learning curve.
Can AskUI automate applications that are not web-based?
Yes, AskUI excels at automating a wide range of applications, including desktop, web, mobile, and even canvas-based UIs. This is a key differentiator compared to some other test automation platforms.
Which platform is better for large-scale testing?
Testsigma, with its cloud-based architecture and extensive device lab, is better suited for large-scale testing efforts. Its ability to scale resources on demand makes it ideal for organizations with demanding testing requirements.
Does AskUI require a cloud connection?
No, AskUI offers on-premise deployment options, which means it can operate without a constant cloud connection. This can be a significant advantage for organizations with strict data security or compliance requirements.
How does AI reduce test maintenance in these platforms?
Both AskUI and Testsigma leverage AI to reduce test maintenance. AskUI's visual recognition technology is less susceptible to UI changes, while Testsigma's GenAI-powered scripting can automatically adapt to some UI modifications.