Why We Wrote This Guide
Recently, we've noticed some confusion in the automation community about different AI computer agents. As the creators of AskUI, we've received many questions about how our Vision Agent compares to Claude's computer use and OpenAI's Operator. While all three tools involve AI interacting with computer interfaces, they serve different purposes and excel in different scenarios. We wrote this guide to help clarify these differences and help you choose the right tool for your specific needs.
Understanding Each Tool's PurposeClaude Computer Use & OpenAI Operator
These are general-purpose AI agents designed to interact with web interfaces. They're part of a broader vision for AI assistants that can help with everyday computer tasks.Real-world examples:• Research planning: Finding flight times, checking hotel availability, and creating a travel itinerary• Data gathering: Collecting information from multiple websites and compiling it into a report• Simple workflow automation: Downloading files, combining PDFs, or filling out web formsAskUI Vision AgentAskUI is a versatile automation platform that handles everything from testing to complex business process automation across all types of applications - web, desktop, and native mobile apps. It excels at both quality assurance and workflow automation, particularly in enterprise environments.
Real-world examples:
• Testing a native iOS banking app across multiple devices
• Automating data entry between a web portal and a desktop ERP system• Validating UI consistency across different platforms
• Running end-to-end tests that span web and native applications
• Extracting data from PDFs and emails to update SAP, Oracle, or Microsoft Dynamics
• Automating invoice processing from email to ERP system
• Moving data between legacy systems and modern applications
• Automating customer data updates across multiple platforms
Key Differences:
Platform Support
• Claude Computer Use & Operator:
Currently focused on web interfaces through virtual machines
• AskUI:
Works across web, desktop applications, and native mobile apps
Use Case Focus
• Claude Computer Use:
General-purpose web assistance and research
• OpenAI Operator:
Task automation and web interaction
• AskUI:
Cross-platform testing and automation
Ideal Scenarios for Each Tool
When to Use Claude Computer Use
• Complex web research tasks• Data gathering across multiple websites
• Tasks that require understanding and synthesizing information
Example scenario:
You need to research competitors' pricing across multiple websites and create a summary report.
When to Use OpenAI Operator
• Web-based workflow automation• Document handling and organization
• Form filling and data entry on websites
Example scenario:
You need to download multiple PDFs from different sources and combine them into a single document.
When to Use AskUI
• Cross-platform testing and automation
• Native mobile app automation
• Enterprise system integration
• Continuous integration/continuous deployment (CI/CD) pipelines
• Business process automation with ERP systems
• PDF and email data extraction and processing
• Legacy system integration• End-to-end workflow automation
Example scenarios:
1. Testing: You need to validate a workflow that starts in a web application, continues in a desktop program, and finishes in a mobile app.
2. Business Process: You need to extract invoice data from PDFs in email attachments and automatically enter them into SAP, including handling attachments and updating related records.
3. System Integration: You need to transfer customer data from a legacy system into Microsoft Dynamics, including validation and error handling.
Current State and Availability
Claude Computer Use
• Available via API for developers
• Requires technical expertise for implementation
• Pricing not yet publicly available• Still in development with ongoing improvements
OpenAI Operator
• Requires ChatGPT Pro subscription ($200/month, and pricing may increase as OpenAI recently stated that current Pro subscription usage levels are not financially sustainable)
• Only available through virtual machine environment
• Limited to web interfaces• Actively evolving with regular updates
AskUI
• Open source core with enterprise features available• Free trial with 500 Asks included• No virtual machine required• Production-ready for immediate implementation• Works across all platforms: web, desktop, and mobile
Advantages and Limitations:
AskUI Advantages
• Open Source Core: Transparent and customizable
• Cross-Platform Support: True native app support, not just web interfaces
• No Virtual Machine Required: Direct interaction with applications
• Speed: Faster execution compared to virtual machine-based solutions
• Self-Healing Automation: Adapts to UI changes automatically
• Enterprise Features: Audit logs, access controls, and security features
• Immediate Availability: No waitlist or special access required
• Simple Integration: Works with existing development workflows
• Natural Language Commands: Intuitive for non-technical users
• Generous Free Trial: 500 Asks to properly test and implement solutions
AskUI Limitations
• Focused on automation and testing rather than general computer tasks
• Requires some technical setup for optimal use• Best suited for structured, repeatable workflows rather than ad-hoc tasks
Getting Started with AskUI
Ready to try AI-powered automation that works across all your platforms?
AskUI offers a comprehensive free trial that includes:
• 500 Asks to build and test your automation scenarios
• Access to all core features• Complete documentation and tutorials
• Community support
Get Started with AskUI Free Trial →Don't just experiment with automation - implement it today.
Your 500 free Asks are waiting.
